» About your hosts » The Brahman Way of Haiku » The mission of WHW »Guestbook »Inform a Friend »Contacts
letter size:

Wonder Haiku Worlds

Login| Register
Site Home| About This Site| About Haiku And Other Genres| Links| Browse Members

Back to list

  

The Grass Grows
 
Posted by Chèvrefeuille Tue, Sep 2nd 2008, 19:21 :: English

every day
grass grows by itself
and so do I

Hindi translation by Rebba Singh. Posted on Wed, Sep 3rd 2008, 02:15

har din

ghaass khud-b-khud bardhey

aur khud hum bhi 


  


Comments
a lot of soul searching depth in your beautiful words
...Chèvrefeuille
try typing 'do' in place of 'am'
like this...
"every day
grass grows by itself
and so do I"...
sounds better ~
to the ears ~ that listen ~ understand ~ silences ~ in english...

when one translates into another language...
one has to accomodate a slightly different expression of the same word...

like i have translated your words...into hindustani...

har din
every day
ghaass *khud-b-khud bardhey
grass (i-am-as-i-am but means *on its own) grows
aur *khud-hum bhi
and (*so-am-i) too

but

if i translate my words back into english...

every day
grass grows on its own
and so *am I too

see its the same as yours
but again...in english...i must change it to
"and so *do I"
(it means the same but it is expressed differently)


i must compliment you...Chèvrefeuille
you write with depth in thought
Rebba Singh Wed, Sep 3rd 2008, 02:19  
  

Dear Rebba,

Thank you for sharing this wonderful comment. I have changed 'am' to 'do'. It deepens the thoughts I had when I wrote this haiku.
What a wonderful translation. God Bless You.
Chèvrefeuille Wed, Sep 3rd 2008, 10:46  
  

Please
login to post comment.
About This Site || About Haiku And Other Genres || Links || Site Home || Browse Members
Copyright 2008 / All rights reserved